Man Felt Sorry for Woman Who Was Ghosted on a Blind Date, so He Decided to Pretend to Be Her Date — Story of the Day

Michael sat at the bar, swirling the ice in his glass before taking another sip of whiskey. The warmth of the alcohol did little to ease the frustration gnawing at him.

His recent breakup with Jen had been a relief more than anything, yet the constant nagging from his parents made it hard to find any peace.

They kept telling him he’d made a “huge mistake,” that he should have proposed to Jen, but Michael knew deep down that he never loved her—not in the way they wanted him to. Their relationship had been more about appearances than any real connection.

He sighed, glancing around the dimly lit bar, trying to shake off the weight of his thoughts. That’s when he noticed her—a woman sitting alone at a table near the window.

She was attractive, but what caught his attention was the sadness in her eyes as she alternated between looking at her phone and staring out the window. It was clear she was waiting for someone who hadn’t shown up.

A waitress approached the bar, breaking his train of thought. Michael couldn’t help but overhear as she placed an order.

The waitress leaned on the bar, catching the bartender’s attention. “That girl over there wants another whiskey sour,” she said, nodding toward the sad woman by the window. “She’s still waiting, hoping he’ll show.”

The bartender shook his head, pouring the drink. “It’s not the first time this has happened,” he muttered.

The waitress sighed. “Blind dates never seem to end well, do they?”

The bartender slid the glass toward her. “No, they don’t,” he agreed. The waitress picked up the drink and walked it over to the lonely woman, offering a small, sympathetic smile.

Michael overheard the conversation between the waitress and bartender, feeling a strange pull toward the lonely girl. Before he knew it, he was on his feet, moving toward her table. This wasn’t like him, but something about her made him want to reach out.

“Hi…” Michael started, his voice trailing off as he realized he didn’t know her name.

“Hailey,” she offered, her eyes searching his face. “Are you Josh?” There was a flicker of hope in her voice.

“Yes, Josh,” Michael said, sliding into the seat across from her. “Sorry I’m late. Work was crazy, a total nightmare.”

Hailey’s expression softened. “Rough day with the patients?”

Michael nodded, trying to piece together the situation. So, Josh was a doctor, he thought. Michael wasn’t, but he was good at thinking on his feet. “Yeah, you know, patients always have something to say about their treatment, prices, or how I look too young to be doing this.”

Hailey’s cheeks flushed. “I didn’t know animals could talk…”

Michael blinked, realizing his mistake. Not a doctor—a vet. “Just joking,” he quickly recovered, flashing a smile. “Or maybe I’ve developed a special talent for understanding animal language.”

Hailey finally laughed, the tension easing from her shoulders. “Honestly, I thought you weren’t going to show up,” she admitted, her voice soft.

“I’d be a fool to leave a girl like you sitting alone in a bar,” Michael said, sincerity in his tone. He couldn’t believe anyone would stand her up, but apparently, Josh was just that—a fool.

Michael and Hailey ordered another round, and as the drinks kept coming, so did the conversation. Michael was surprised by how easy it was to talk to Hailey.

She had a quick wit and a warm smile that made him feel comfortable. He found out they both loved old black-and-white movies, and they laughed about how neither of them could dance but still enjoyed trying.

Michael hadn’t felt this good in a long time. Being with Hailey was refreshing. She wasn’t just beautiful; she was smart and funny too. He found himself genuinely enjoying her company, something he hadn’t experienced in a while.

The night felt special, like they were in their own little world, where nothing else mattered but the stories they were sharing and the laughter that came with them.

As the night wound down, Michael offered to drive Hailey home. The car ride was quiet, filled with a comfortable silence that didn’t need to be broken.

When they reached her place, Hailey didn’t get out right away. Instead, she turned to Michael, her eyes searching his face, as if she was trying to make a decision.

“Can I kiss you?” Michael asked softly, not wanting to assume anything.

Hailey nodded, and Michael leaned in, their lips meeting in a gentle kiss. It wasn’t just a kiss; it was a spark that ignited something deep inside him. For the first time in what felt like forever, Michael felt alive, emotions swirling inside him like a storm.

Hailey invited him in, and he accepted. But instead of things moving too fast, they spent the night talking. They sat on the couch, sharing stories from their childhoods, laughing about terrible dates they’d both been on, and dreaming about what the future might hold.

It wasn’t physical, but it was deeply intimate—two people connecting on a level that went far beyond just attraction. As the night faded into early morning, Michael realized he hadn’t felt this connected to anyone in a long time.

After that night with Hailey, Michael couldn’t shake the guilt gnawing at him. She still thought he was Josh, and every time he thought about it, his stomach twisted in knots.

But he couldn’t deny how good it felt to be with her. The connection they had was something special, and Michael wasn’t ready to let it go.

Determined not to mess things up, Michael spent the days before their next date preparing. He dove into the world of veterinary work, watching interviews with vets and even reading a book by one.

He wanted to make sure he could keep up with their conversations, even if it meant living a lie a little longer. He didn’t feel great about it, but he convinced himself it was worth it if it meant spending more time with Hailey.

When their second date rolled around, Michael was ready. He came armed with interesting stories about animals and their care, stories he hoped would impress Hailey. The evening went well, but as they left the restaurant, the weight of his deception grew heavier.

As they walked to her car, Michael knew he couldn’t keep the truth hidden any longer. He had to tell her, even if it meant losing her.

Michael’s heart pounded as he looked at Hailey. He took a deep breath. “Hailey?”

“Yes, Josh?” she responded, her eyes meeting his.

“There’s something I need to tell you,” Michael said, his voice shaky.

“I’m listening.”

Michael opened his mouth to speak, ready to confess, when suddenly his eyes caught a familiar sight—Jen, his ex, walking toward them with his parents. His heart sank.

“Oh, Michael!” his father, Ed, called out with a broad smile. “How wonderful to see you here!”

Hailey looked at Michael, confused. “Do you know these people?” she asked.

Michael felt a wave of panic. “That’s actually part of what I wanted to tell you.”

“I don’t understand,” Hailey said, her brow furrowing.

Jen reached them, slipping her arm through Michael’s. “Michael, who’s this girl?” she asked, her tone sharp. “Aren’t you going to introduce her to your fiancée?”

“Fiancée?!” Hailey and Michael exclaimed together.

“That’s right,” Jen said, a smug smile spreading across her face as she flashed a ring on her finger.

Hailey’s eyes widened in disbelief. “Josh, what’s going on? Are you engaged? And why are they calling you Michael?” she asked, her voice rising with confusion.

Michael’s heart dropped. “Because that’s my real name,” he said quietly, shame washing over him.

“What? Your name isn’t Josh? Are you even a vet?” Hailey asked, her voice shaking now.

Jen laughed, the sound cold and mocking. “A vet? Sweetie, he’s a journalist,” she said.

Hailey looked at Michael, her eyes filled with betrayal. “What? I don’t understand…” she whispered, more to herself than to anyone else.

“Back at the bar, I overheard that the guy you were supposed to meet didn’t show up, and I decided to pretend to be him,” he confessed, his voice barely above a whisper.

Hailey’s face twisted in anger and hurt. “So you went on a date with me out of pity?!” she snapped. “While being engaged!”

“No, it’s not like that at all!” Michael pleaded, desperate to make her understand. “I really liked you, and Jen is my ex. I’m not connected to her anymore. I don’t know what kind of show my parents and she are putting on right now, but I’m telling the truth.”

“And why should I believe that’s the truth?” Hailey asked, her voice cold and distant.

“Because I really like you,” Michael said, his voice trembling with sincerity.

Hailey stared at him for a moment, then shook her head. “Goodbye, Josh… or Michael, I don’t even know who you are,” she said, turning away and walking toward the road, her movements stiff with anger.

Michael watched in despair as she hailed a taxi. He started to follow, but Ed stepped in front of him, blocking his path. “What are you doing?” Ed demanded. “We arranged for Jen to forgive you for breaking up with her, we even bought the ring for you.”

“I didn’t ask for that!” Michael yelled. “I don’t need you or Jen.”

Ed’s eyes narrowed. “And who do you need? A woman you barely know?” he asked, his tone harsh.

Michael’s eyes flashed with defiance. “At least she’s the only one who hasn’t tried to decide how I should live my life,” he shot back, pushing past Ed. But it was too late—Hailey had already climbed into the taxi, and it sped away into the night.

“Damn!” Michael shouted, the word echoing in the empty street as he ran to his car.

Michael chased after Hailey’s taxi, his mind racing with panic. He ignored the shouts of his parents and Jen, their voices fading into the background.

As he pulled alongside the taxi, he saw Hailey in the back seat, her face wet with tears. Desperation surged through him. He rolled down his window and shouted, “Hailey, please! Roll down the window!” But she didn’t respond, her gaze fixed forward.

Without thinking, Michael swerved his car in front of the taxi, blocking its path. The sudden stop caused a traffic jam, and angry drivers began honking. Hailey, startled, opened the door and stepped out. Michael quickly got out of his car and ran toward her.

“Hailey! Wait!” Michael shouted, his voice cracking with desperation.

Hailey stopped, turning to face him. “Why? So you can lie to me again?” she snapped, her eyes narrowing.

Michael swallowed hard. “I’m sorry. I wanted to tell you the truth, but I was scared. I didn’t want to lose you,” he said, his voice pleading.

Hailey shook her head, her disappointment clear. “I don’t want a relationship built on lies, Michael. You’ve already lost me,” she said firmly.

“I’m sorry,” Michael repeated, his voice barely above a whisper.

Hailey’s eyes filled with tears as she spoke. “You know, I thought I finally found someone real. Someone smart, funny, and kind. We had so much in common. But it was all fake, wasn’t it? It was all a lie.”

“No, Hailey,” Michael protested, stepping closer. “I only lied about my name and job. Everything else was real. That night we spent together, the things I told you, I’ve never shared that with anyone before. That was real.”

Hailey stared at him, her expression unreadable. “Why should I believe anything you say now?” she asked, her voice trembling.

“Please, Hailey,” Michael begged, his heart in his throat. “Give me one more chance. I promise, no more lies. Just the truth from now on.”

As they stood there, cars began honking, the drivers impatient and annoyed. One of them leaned out of their window and yelled, “Come on, give the guy a chance so we can move!”

Michael turned to the crowd, frustrated. “Don’t pressure her!” he shouted back, then looked at Hailey, his eyes full of hope. “So, what do you say?”

Hailey stared at him for what felt like an eternity. Finally, she sighed, a small, reluctant smile tugging at her lips. “One last chance,” she said, her voice soft.

Michael’s heart leaped. He felt a wave of relief and joy wash over him. “Thank you,” he said, his voice thick with emotion. He wanted to pull her into a hug, to kiss her, to show her how much this meant to him.

Hailey stepped closer, her eyes locking onto his. “But promise me, no more lies,” she said, her voice serious.

“I promise,” Michael replied without hesitation, his voice steady.

Hailey leaned in slightly, and for a moment, Michael thought she might kiss him. But instead, she brushed past him and got back into the taxi. “Text me,” she said over her shoulder.

“Definitely,” Michael said, watching her go. He then hurried back to his car, letting out a deep breath as the drivers around him finally got their chance to move.

Tell us what you think about this story and share it with your friends. It might inspire them and brighten their day.

If you enjoyed this story, read this one: My marriage was falling apart, and when I discovered my husband was cheating with his boss’s wife, he threw me out like a stray dog. What he didn’t know was that I had a secret, one that would help me take back control of my life and give him exactly what he deserved. Read the full story here.

This piece is inspired by stories from the everyday lives of our readers and written by a professional writer. Any resemblance to actual names or locations is purely coincidental. All images are for illustration purposes only. Share your story with us; maybe it will change someone’s life. If you would like to share your story, please send it to info@amomama.com.